Higgs the musical: the sound of the ‘God particle’

By Archil Kobakhidze, University of Melbourne

The July 4 discovery of a particle that closely resembles the Higgs boson opens a new era in science: it should help us understand some fundamental mysteries, such as how microscopic particles attain their masses, or how gigantic galaxies and stars are formed.


The supposed importance of the Higgs boson in shaping our universe and, ultimately, our own existence is fully reflected in its popular nickname, the God particle.

But what do the recent results sound like? That’s a question we now have an answer to, thanks to a process called sonification.

It took 48 years from the theoretical prediction of the Higgs boson by British theoretical physicist Peter Higgs, and independently by Robert Brout and Francois Englert, and Gerald Guralnik, C.R. Hagen and Tom Kibble, to its apparent discovery using two major detectors at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) – the ATLAS detector and the CMS detector.

Chris Halderman

Largely because of its supposed universal role in generating masses for all the other particles, the Higgs boson is rather hard to detect. Once produced in high energy collisions of protons, it decays very quickly, long before we have a chance to photograph it. Scientists can’t catch the Higgs boson directly, but they can detect some particles the Higgs boson decay into.

Different product particles manifest themselves differently in the detector. By looking at which particles are detected, and tracing them back, one can infer that a Higgs boson was created in the detector.

This is an incredibly complicated process, because each second about a billion collisions happen at the LHC and many particles produced in those collisions behave similarly to the products of the Higgs boson decay.

Initial, raw data collected from the detectors are in the form of electronic signals (streams of ones and zeros). These raw data are analysed and processed using powerful computing software, and are converted step by step into more sensible data, such as the number of detector hits, energy deposited in the detector, and so on. Using this processed data, scientists are then able to identify particles in the detector.

Information collected this way is displayed in the form of various graphs and histograms, such as the one shown below.

Mass distribution for the two-photon channel CERN

The clearly visible bump around 126 gigaelectronvolts (GeV) corresponds, it is believed, to a Higgs boson.

But are there ways to “witness” the supposed God particle other than in boring graphs? Enter sonification – the process of converting scientific data into sounds.

A team of researchers lead by Domenico Vicinanza from DANTE (Delivery of Advanced Network Technology to Europe) sonified the data collected by the ATLAS detector. As a result, the graph shown above has been turned into the sheet music you can see below.

Higgs boson sonification sheet music GÉANT

Semiquavers in the sonification correspond to data points on the graph separated by 5 GeV intervals. As numerical values of data points increase or decrease, the pitch of the notes grows or diminishes accordingly.

The bump corresponding to the God particle is represented by an F (Fa) note which is two octaves above the preceding F (Fa) note, a C (Do) note which is the most acute note in the music (also two octaves above the subsequent C note) representing the peak of the Higgs, and a E (Mi) note.

The tune is surprisingly catchy and listenable, as you’ll discover below.

It may be hard to see how sonification would be useful for purely scientific purposes. Strange as it may sound, scientists in their studies are usually more comfortable with formal numbers and “boring” graphs than their musical representations.

But sonification can definitely help the general public feel and accept fundamental discoveries as a part of global knowledge, just as art or music masterpieces are associated with the cultural heritage of civilisations.

Sonification plays a role in public awareness of science. After all, significant discoveries, such as the potential discovery of the God particle, contribute to society by producing fundamental knowledge that ultimately shapes our understanding of the world around us and our place in it.

Further reading:

CERN discovers a Higgs-like particle: let the party (and head-scratching) begin Explainer: the Higgs boson particle

Archil Kobakhidze does not work for, consult to, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has no relevant affiliations.

FIFA insist doping not a problem in soccer

FIFA’s chief medical officer Jiri Dvorak has insisted that doping is not a significant problem in soccer.


While athletics has suffered some high-profile positive tests over the last two months and cycling began the year with the news that Lance Armstrong finally owned up to his spurious past, football has largely avoided any negative publicity with regards illicit drug-taking.

There was the Diego Maradona positive test from the 1994 World Cup and several Italian-based players were banned for doping in the early 2000s but football’s record on drugs is relatively good compared to certain other sports.

And according to Dvorak, that’s because there isn’t much of it happening.

“I am confident that there is no systematic doping in football,” he told FIFA’s official website on Friday. “There is no systematic doping culture in football. I am confident of this.

“Of course there are individual cases, for sure. We do more than 30,000 sampling procedures every year and we have between 70 to 90 positive cases, most of them for marijuana and cocaine and we have also anabolic steroids, but these are individual cases.”

FIFA launched biological profiling back in February, similar to the biological passport in cycling.

It was tested at June’s Confederations Cup and will be again at next year’s World Cup.

Dvorak says FIFA will try to get other organisations on board.

“And now we are also in discussion with UEFA and other confederations to start this biological profile in the confederations so all the top players will be registered,” he added.

“And if we have a suspicion then we go into the more intelligent and targeted testing.”

US, Israel condemn Palestinian UN vote

The United States and Israel downplayed Thursday the Palestinians’ new upgraded status at the UN, saying it changed nothing in actual practice and even made peace with the Jewish state a remoter prospect.


Palestinians rejoiced at the historic albeit largely symbolic vote at the UN General Assembly in New York, firing guns into the air in Ramallah in the occupied West Bank, shooting off fireworks and embracing each other with glee.

In between the two ends of the spectrum were major powers like Britain, which said it respected the vote but abstained on the grounds that the Palestinians had not unconditionally agreed to negotiations on a lasting two-state deal with Israel.

Britain pledged support for efforts to reach an elusive peace accord, as did France, which voted for the resolution but called on Israel and the Palestinians to resume peace talks without conditions and as soon as possible.

The Vatican welcomed the 138-9 vote, saying it reflected the majority sentiment of the international community and the Holy See had long encouraged more global involvement to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

“Peace needs courageous decisions,” it said in a statement.

But top US diplomats warned the Palestinians that they had essentially achieved nothing, while Israel sounded as angry as the Palestinians did joyful.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office said Palestinian president Mahmud Abbas’s speech before the General Assembly ahead of the vote on the status upgrade was “defamatory and venomous.”

“The world watched a defamatory and venomous speech that was full of mendacious propaganda against the IDF (army) and the citizens of Israel,” the statement said.

The American ambassador to the United Nations, Susan Rice, said the Palestinians’ joy would be short-lived.

“Today’s grand announcements will soon fade and the Palestinian people will wake up tomorrow to find little of their lives has changed, save (that) the prospects of a durable peace have receded,” she said.

“This resolution does not establish that Palestine is a state,” she said, echoing an earlier speech by the ambassador to Israel. “Today’s vote should not be misconstrued by any as constituting eligibility for UN membership.”

Rice said that “only through direct negotiations between the parties can the Palestinians and the Israelis achieve the peace that both deserve.”

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, speaking in Washington, used exactly the same language to denounce a decision that she said “places further obstacles in the path to peace.”

The United States and Israel were among just nine countries bucking global support for a resolution giving Palestine non-member status at the United Nations.

Speaking prior to the vote, Netanyahu said in Jerusalem: “The decision at the United Nations today won’t change anything on the ground.” He added, “It won’t promote the establishment of a Palestinian state; it will distance it.

“Israel’s hand is always extended in peace, but a Palestinian state will not be established without (a Palestinian) recognition of the State of Israel as the Jewish people’s state,” Netanyahu said.

Among the allies of Israel and the United States was Canada, whose foreign minister John Baird said giving Palestine non-member observer status, a step on the path to full UN membership, “undermines the core” of attempts to broker a Palestinian-Israeli peace deal.

But nothing would spoil the Palestinians’ big day.

The hardline Hamas movement, which had opposed its rival Abbas’s drive for the status change on grounds it was unilateral and not a product of consensus, welcomed the vote as a victory.

And while some in Ramallah recognized it was a half-triumph, they savored it nonetheless.

“I’m happy they declared the state even though it’s only a moral victory. There are a lot of sharks out there, but it feels good,” 39-year-old Rashid al-Kor told AFP.

Ethar al-Asmar, a teacher, was pragmatic about the approval.

“Israel isn’t going anywhere,” she admitted. But, she said, the moment felt historic nonetheless.

“We have been waiting for this for so long. I never thought this day would come.”

US slams CNN use of slain envoy’s diary

The US State Department has accused CNN of ‘distasteful’ reporting after it used the contents of a private diary kept by slain US ambassador to Libya Christopher Stevens without the consent of his family.


Senior State Department aide Philippe Reines told reporters in a statement over the weekend that the television network engaged in “atrocious behavior” in making use of the late envoy’s diary as it reported on events leading up to his death at the hands of militants who stormed the US consulate in Benghazi earlier this month.

Reines said CNN removed the journal from the US mission in Libya after the deadly attack, which also killed three other US diplomatic staff, and then went on to use information obtained from it against the wishes of the diplomat’s family.

Reines said the family told a network executive in a conference call they they did not want the journal used until they had had an opportunity to review its contents.

CNN said it felt the public had a right to know what it had learned from multiple sources about the fears of a terrorist threat before the attack on the consulate.

“We reached out to the family of Ambassador Stevens within hours of retrieving the journal and returned it through a third party, within less than 24 hours from the time we found it. Out of respect to the family, we have not quoted from or shown the journal,” it said.

What CNN is “not owning up to is reading and transcribing Chris’s diary well before bothering to tell the family or anyone else that they took it from the site of the attack,” Reines wrote in a lengthy memo sent to reporters on Sunday.

“When they finally did tell them, they completely ignored the wishes of the family, and ultimately broke their pledge made to them only hours after they witnessed the return to the Unites States of Chris’s remains,” he said.

Reines cited reports by CNN last week claiming it had obtained “exclusive information about the climate that led up” to the storming of the US diplomatic post in Libya.

Specifically, the network said, it had learned from “a source” that Stevens in the months before his death “talked about being worried about what he called the never-ending security threats, specifically in Benghazi,” CNN news anchor Anderson Cooper said in one report last week.

“The source (is) telling us that the ambassador specifically mentioned the rise in Islamic extremism, the growing Al-Qaeda presence in Libya, and said that he was on an Al-Qaeda hit list,” Cooper said.

What CNN did not reveal, Reines said, is that Stevens’ journal was the basis for much of that reporting.

“Whose first instinct is to remove from a crime scene the diary of a man killed along with three other Americans serving our country, read it, transcribe it, email it around your newsroom for others to read, and only when their curiosity is fully satisfied thinks to call the family or notify the authorities?” Reines wrote.

He added that only in subsequent reporting did Cooper reveal that “some of that information was found in a personal journal of Ambassador Stevens in his handwriting.”

“At their request, we returned that journal to them. We reported what we found newsworthy in the ambassador’s writings. Our reporting followed up on what we found newsworthy, as I said, in the ambassador’s writings,” Cooper said in a report on Friday.

Reines said, however, that Stevens’s relatives had specifically requested that CNN not issue any reports based on the journal or even make mention of its existence, and that CNN had reneged on its agreements to abide by the family’s wishes.

CNN issued a statement over the weekend defending its actions.

“The reason CNN ultimately reported Friday on the existence of the journal was because leaks to media organizations incorrectly suggested CNN had not quickly returned the journal, which we did,” the television network wrote.

The network’s position appears not to have mollified officials at State Department, however.

“Given the truth of how this was handled, CNN patting themselves on the back is disgusting,” Reines said.

Zach attack pays off as Johnson hits the front

While the American was making an electric start to the third major championship of the year, world number two Rory McIlroy’s troubles continued as he crashed to an eight-over 79.


Mark O’Meara was flying a surprise flag for the ‘golden oldies’. The 56-year-old American moved to four-under through 12 holes, level in second place with Spain’s Rafael Cabrera-Bello (67).

Most of the players were finding the treacherous knee-high rough difficult to cope with and scores were generally high on the banks of the Firth of Forth.

The parched and dry links course was also making it tough for the 156-strong field to control the ball on the fairways and the greens.

Johnson fared the best and he waved his putter like a magic wand to birdie the third, sixth and seventh and eagle the long fifth.

The 37-year-old made further inroads on par at the par-four 12th before dropping his only stroke of the day at the 14th.

“Any time you shoot under par in an Open or a major, for that matter, you have to be putting at least somewhat decent and I putted great,” Johnson told reporters as temperatures rose to a balmy 80 degrees in East Lothian.

“This is the Open and you expect difficult conditions but a couple of the pin positions were pretty tough.”


Johnson was pipped for the John Deere Classic title in Illinois on Sunday when he was beaten in a playoff by 19-year-old compatriot Jordan Speith.

“I felt great about last week, I’ll be honest with you,” he said. “I don’t want to say I lost the golf tournament but I certainly had ample opportunities to win it.

“The last nine holes in particular I hit great shots, just didn’t make many putts. If anything from last week, what I’ve embraced is the fact I’m playing great and I can put that into play, and I’m certainly confident in what I’m doing.”

O’Meara matched Johnson’s start with a barnstorming run of four birdies in six holes. Another birdie at the ninth took him to the turn in 31 before he faltered with a bogey at the 10th.

At the other end of the leaderboard, McIlroy dropped strokes at the fourth and fifth before getting one back with a birdie at the seventh.

McIlroy then frittered away shot after shot on the back nine, carding double-bogey sixes at the 12th and 15th, and he sported a look of sad resignation when he walked off the green at the end of another disappointing effort.

The Northern Irishman has struggled with his new Nike clubs all year, after deciding to ditch his old Titleist equipment, and is still searching for his first win of 2013 after topping the money lists on both sides of the Atlantic last season.

Phil Mickelson, bidding for back-to-back wins after landing the Scottish Open title in Inverness last week, fired an encouraging 69.

U.S. Open champion Justin Rose slipped to a 75 while title holder Ernie Els could manage only a 74 that included a double-bogey six at the 16th where he needed three strokes to get out of a greenside bunker.

Six-times major winner Nick Faldo, in his first competitive outing since 2010, marked his 56th birthday by returning a 79. Playing partners Tom Watson and Fred Couples fared better with matching 75s.

Late starter Tiger Woods made a poor start, bogeying the first hole after launching a wayward hooked drive into the rough.

The world number one then returned to level-par with a birdie at the fourth.

(Editing by Stephen Wood)

Afghanistan dominates Biden talks in India

US Vice President Joe Biden has held talks with Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh as he sought to calm fears over the exit of US troops from Afghanistan and capitalise on growing investment opportunities.


Biden also met President Pranab Mukherjee and a top opposition party figure, Sushma Swaraj, and will be guest of honour at a dinner hosted by his counterpart Hamid Ansari in the capital later on Tuesday.

Biden, the most senior US official to visit India since President Barack Obama in 2010, discussed with Singh the security situation in Afghanistan during a 75-minute meeting, according to the Press Trust of India (PTI) news agency.

The vice president has said the world’s two largest democracies share common goals on a range of regional security issues.

But there is widespread unease among Indian leaders over what will happen in Afghanistan once US combat troops have left in 2014, with many fearing that Pakistan has most to gain from the withdrawal.

During talks, the pair confirmed that Singh will meet Obama during a six-day visit to Washington from September 20, PTI quoted sources as saying.

They also discussed implementation of a landmark civil nuclear deal and ways to build up two-way commerce, the sources said.

Boosting bilateral trade is expected to form the cornerstone of a keynote speech Biden is scheduled to make in Mumbai on Wednesday.

India has spent more than $US2 billion ($A2.1 billion) of aid in Afghanistan since the Taliban, hardline Islamists who were strong allies of Pakistan, were toppled in a 2001 US-led invasion.

Even though plans for talks between the US and the Taliban collapsed last month, the possible return to power of the insurgents alarms many in India.

Parents arrested over UK fire deaths

The parents of six children killed in a house fire have been arrested on suspicion of murder.


Mick Philpott and his wife Mairead were arrested in Derby city centre in connection with the blaze at the house on May 11.

Their children Jade, 10, and brothers John, nine, Jack, seven, Jessie, six, and Jayden, five, all died in the fire, and a sixth sibling Duwayne, 13, died of his injuries in Birmingham Children’s Hospital two days’ later.

Petrol was used to start the blaze at the house in Victory Road, Allenton, Derby, police have revealed.

Derbyshire Police said a 55-year-old man and a 31-year-old woman from Derby were arrested together but did not name them.

Five days after the fire, Mr and Mrs Philpott faced the media in an emotional press conference.

Mr Philpott thanked those who tried to rescue his children and spoke of how he and his wife had decided to donate Duwayne’s organs for transplant, saying it “takes a bit of the pain away”.

The 55-year-old, who is believed to have fathered 17 children, was said by police to have made “valiant” efforts to rescue his children during the blaze.

Dubbed Shameless Mick in 2007 after demanding a larger council house, he is well known in the local community because of media reports about his large family, and has also appeared in a reality TV show alongside former government minister Ann Widdecombe.

This morning a mobile police office van was parked outside the Philpotts’ semi-detached house and a uniformed officer stood guard outside the taped off property, where numerous floral tributes still lay. Announcing the arrests today, Assistant Chief Constable Steve Cotterill urged anyone with “crucial information” to come forward.

He said: “I suspect there may still be people with crucial information who have not yet come forward to speak to us.

Timeline: Liberia under Charles Taylor

Key dates in the life of warlord turned Liberian president Charles Taylor, who has been convicted by an international court of arming rebels who killed and mutilated thousands in Sierra Leone.


– December 24, 1989: Taylor leads a rebellion by the National Patriotic Front of Liberia (NPFL).

The uprising leads to one of Africa’s most brutal civil wars, involving at least seven rival factions and claiming between 250,000 and 300,000 lives.

In June, 1990, a month-long siege of the capital Monrovia takes place. In August, the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) sends a peacekeeping force which secures Monrovia in October.

– March 23, 1991: The notorious Revolutionary United Front (RUF), led by former army officer Foday Sankoh, crosses the border from Liberia into Sierra Leone.

The civil war, which lasts until January 2002, leaves some 120,000 dead and thousands of civilians mutilated.

The wars are marked by atrocities by drug-fuelled combatants who gain notoriety for murders, systematic rapes, abductions, amputations and the kidnapping of thousands of children who were then forced to fight among their ranks.

– July 19, 1997: Taylor wins elections in Liberia and is sworn in as president on August 2, marking the culmination of a peace accord.

– August-September, 1999: Fighting rages in Liberia between government troops and forces in the north.

– January 25, 2001: The United Nations accuses Taylor of fuelling the civil war in Sierra Leone and profiting from trade in “blood diamonds” and arms traffic, and slaps sanctions on Liberia.

In June, 2003, a UN-mandated court in Freetown announces it has indicted Taylor for war crimes relating to Sierra Leone’s civil war.

– August 11, 2003: Taylor, under pressure from rebels and the international community, hands power to his deputy and heads for exile in Nigeria.

– March-July, 2004: The UN and the United States freeze Taylor’s assets.

– March 29, 2006: Taylor is arrested in Nigeria, deported to Liberia and taken to Freetown where he is put behind bars at the UN special court.

On June 20 he is transferred to the Netherlands.

– June 4, 2007: Taylor’s trial opens in the Hague, to which he was transferred for security reasons. The trial wraps up on March 11, 2011.

– April 26, 2012: Taylor becomes the first former head of state convicted by a world court since the World War II Nuremberg trials.

Sharks, skulls feature in Hirst retrospective

British artist Damien Hirst this week opens his first major retrospective in typically brash style, with expensive merchandise sitting alongside key works like his dead sharks and diamond skull.


From Wednesday for five months the Tate Modern gallery in London will showcase the work of the enfant terrible-turned-multi-millionaire as part of a festival of arts which has its finale at the 2012 Olympics.

The exhibition, which opens on Wednesday and will run until September 9, features 70 works including classics like “The Physical Impossibility of Death in the Mind of Someone Living”, a shark suspended in formaldehyde.

Another major draw will be “For the Love of God”, a life-sized platinum cast of an 18th-century skull encrusted with 8,601 diamonds, which will be on display under tight security in the Tate’s massive turbine hall.

But as well as seeing Hirst’s artworks on show, visitors can go to the gift shop and spend £36,800 ($A56,508) on a plastic skull decorated in the style of one of Hirst’s so-called spin paintings.

For £700 ($A1,074) they can get a limited edition roll of wallpaper with prints from his butterfly series of paintings, a butterfly-print deckchair for £310 ($A476) and a spot painting skateboard with signature for £480 ($A737).

The 47-year-old, who shot to fame in the 1990s as one of the so-called “Young British Artists” rejected criticisms that he had become more of a self-promoter interested in making money.

“You get the Mona Lisa and then you get the postcards, the T-shirts, the mouse-pad, the earrings and the mugs,” Hirst told reporters on Monday.

“One thing is the artwork and the other is getting it out there and I’ve always been torn between the two.”


The retrospective has drawn mixed reactions from Britain’s art critics, whom Hirst has long divided.

Julian Spalding, a critic and former curator who has written a book called “Con Art — Why You Ought To Sell Your Damien Hirst While You Can”, said the artist’s work would soon become “worthless financially”.

“The bubble that is Con Art blew up, like the sub-prime mortgage business, in the smoke and mirrors world of financial markets, where fortunes have been make on nothing,” he wrote in the Independent newspaper.

In September 2008, just as the bank Lehman Brothers was going bust, Hirst made headlines when he sold his own work direct through Sotheby’s auction house and raised an astonishing £111 million ($A170 million).

But Ann Gallagher, the curator of the Hirst retrospective, rejected the criticism and said Hirst’s work had long been interested in the relationship between art and commerce.

“I think visitors that are just walking in this exhibition and if they haven’t seen any pictures of his work, they may be startled by some of the exhibits,” she said.

She said Hirst’s work focuses on traditional themes such as life and death, but is also “very interested in belief in value systems…. that includes science, it includes religion, it includes art, and also wealth.”

Hirst, born in 1965, was brought up by his mother in the northern English city of Leeds.

He burst onto the scene with his early works including the pickled shark but his reputation in Britain has dipped in recent years, with criticism that much of his output is produced in workshops.

The retrospective includes not only the sharks but other animals suspended in formaldehyde in glass cases; a cow and a calf (“Mother and Child Divided”), sheep and fish.

Also on show will be “A Thousand Years”, featuring a cow’s head, flies and an insect-killing light element.

Works fashioned from medical instruments will be on display, along with rooms full of the famous spot paintings, in which Hirst demands of the painters in his workshop that no colour be repeated next to itself.

Goodes ‘gutted’ by racial slur

Sydney Swans player Adam Goodes says he was called an “ape” by a Collingwood fan in last night’s clash at the MCG.


Goodes was visibly distressed towards the end of the game, pointing out the fan to security staff who later ejected the young girl.

She’s believed to be 13 years of age.

Her comments come in the indigenous round of the AFL, and as the league launches its anti-racism campaign.

Goodes says it’s vital players and the community are united in the fight against racism.

“Racism has no place in our industry, it has no place in society, hopefully any person out there that’s been named-called, that’s been verbally abused, can stand up for themselves after seeing what happend last night.”

Goodes says it is not the first time he has been subjected to racial slurs, but that this latest attack has hit him hard.

“When I saw it was a young girl, I was just like ‘really?’. I was just like ‘how could that happen?’ This week is a celebration of our people, our culture.

“It’s not her fault. Unfortunately it’s what she hears, it’s the environment she’s grown up in that makes her think it’s OK to call people names.

“She would have no idea how it makes someone feel, calling someone an ape. She’s 13, she’s uneducated. If she wants to pick up the phone and apologise, I’ll take that call.

He says when asked by police he refused to press charges against the girl and urged people not to start a ‘witch hunt’ against the girl over the incident.

Instead he says there should be more education on racism and how it can hurt people.

“It affected me so much I couldn’t be on the ground to celebrate a victory last night, to celebrate indigenous round.

“I’m still shattered; personally it’s tough.”

AFL chief executive Andrew Demetriou says it’s disappointing to have an incident of racism in the league’s Indigenous round.

Mr Demetriou says he will offer support and counselling to the 13-year-old girl and her parents to assure they’re not the target of unnecessary retailiation.

He says while the AFL has come a long way in raising awareness in racism, there’s clearly a long way to go.

“But I again remind everyone this is a 13-year-old girl. And we need to be very, very careful. Having said that, I want to reiterate again though, we have a zero tolerance policy around these issues. You’ve seen the great awareness campaign of this week for our indigenous round, the great contribution that our indigenous players make to the game, the great contribution that this code makes to this nation when we talk about the significant role that indigenous Australia plays in this nation.”

Geelong captain Joel Selwood has led the tributes to Sydney AFL star Adam Goodes who was visibly distressed after being the victim of the racial taunt during Friday night’s MCG match.

Dual Brownlow Medallist Goodes was arguably best-afield in Sydney’s 47-point win over Collingwood in the round-nine fixture with 30 disposals and three goals.

However the 33-year-old left the field shaking his head late in the game and went straight into the change rooms to compose himself after clashing with a female fan in the closing stages of the contest.

The fan was evicted from the stadium after Goodes stood only metres away and pointed directly at her in a bid to identify the Collingwood supporter to security staff.

“Much respect for Adam Goodes on all fronts tonight,” Selwood said on Twitter.

Sydney midfielder Dan Hannebery said the incident was sad, while Richmond forward Jack Riewoldt was speechless.

“The person who did that has to have a hard look at themselves,” Hannebery told afl.com.au website.

“It is a disgrace considering the era that we’re in. It’s just completely unacceptable.

“I’m really shocked.”

Riewoldt said on Twitter: “Something clearly said to Adam Goodes, sitting on the couch speechless and really flat! #bloodydisappointing.”

West Coast ruckman Nic Naitanui, whose parents are from Fiji, said: “Not to assume the worst, but to disrespect a legend on Indigenous Round is appalling.

“Racial Vilification has no place in sport and goodesy dealt with it like a champ. Lets NOT let it shadow how well he performed tonight tho,” Naitanui added.

Melbourne onballer Nathan Jones said: “Racial vilification has no place in footy or society. Ignorance is no excuse, What a legend & icon @adamroy37 is for our game. #inspiring.”